Consigning at Penny Pincher Boutique is easy!

At Penny Pincher Boutique we consign luxury designer brands. We accept women’s items; shoes, handbags, clothing, jewelry (fine and costume), accessories, travel bags and small leather accessories. We also accept men’s watches, travel bags, ties, and small accessories.

  • Appointments are necessary to consign, everything must be in excellent condition, cleaned, pressed and clothes on hangers to be accepted. Clothing Items are consigned seasonally; please refer to the schedule below before making an appointment.
  • Appointments are scheduled for Tuesdays, Wednesdays, Fridays & Saturdays.
  • We DO NOT accept Wedding Gowns, Bridesmaids Dresses, Menswear or Children's Clothing.

In addition, we consign a mix of eclectic and modern home furnishings and accessories. Such as lamps, side tables, ottomans, Tiffany & Baccarat crystal, framed prints, hand-made area rugs and the list goes on…

If you have home furnishings and would like to consign them please email photos, prices and descriptions to

We also provide a “white glove” private service to your home within NY, NJ, and CT areas. Please call (914) 241-2134 or email to discuss at


January: Cruise-wear (specialty vacation attire)
  • Cover-ups
  • Dresses
  • Hats
  • Sandals
  • Bags (not canvas beach bags)
  • Tropical colors
February-April: Spring
  • ¾ length and short sleeves (no long sleeves)
  • Capri, full- length pants (no shorts)
  • Lightweight jackets
  • Dressy spring
  • Open toe shoes and sandals, flats (not summer shoes)
  • Fashion accessories: scarves, handbags, sunglasses, etc.
  • Light colors
May-June: Summer
  • ¾ length, short sleeves, tanks, sleeveless
  • Shorts, capri and full-length summer pants, jeans
  • Sandals, flip-flops, flats
  • Fashion accessories: scarves, handbags, sunglasses, etc.
  • Bright colors
August-October: Fall
  • Full-length pants, jeans
  • Lightweight jackets & blazers, leather, suede, rain coats, trench coats, sweater wraps
  • Enclosed shoes, flats and fashion boots
  • ¾ or long sleeves tops and blouses, turtlenecks, lightweight or short sleeve sweaters
  • Fashion accessories: scarves, handbags, sunglasses, etc.
  • Autumn colors
November-December: Winter (Furs)
  • Long sleeves shirts, blouses and sweaters
  • Full-length pants
  • Winter coats and furs
  • Enclosed shoes, boots including winter boots
  • Dressy holiday party attire: sequins, sparkles etc.
  • Winter accessories: gloves, scarves, hats, furs etc.
  • Fashion accessories: scarves, handbags, sunglasses, etc.
  • Dark colors
  • Fashion accessories: scarves, handbags, sunglasses, jewelry, small leather accessories, etc.